Category Archives: Women

This Memorial Day, Let’s Remember Women in War

Now that qualified women can enter combat officially, it’s a good time to remember the many roles women have played during wartime, whether military or civilian.

Writer Frank Moore dubbed classical women during the Civil War “Angels of Mercy” as they rolled bandages and patriotically waited for their men to come home. But he also understood that “the story of war will never be fully or fairly written if the achievements of women in it are untold.@ He knew that there were women soldiers in the Civil War, honored in DeAnne Blanton and Lauren Cook’s book They Fought Like Demons. The stories of hundreds of women who assumed male aliases, wore men=s uniforms, and charged into battle as both Union and Confederate soldiers are compelling. Mary Ann Pittman and Loretta Valesques, for example, both raised a company of soldiers and later became spies.

More than a hundred years later, Marge Piercy=s 1980s epic novel Gone to Soldiers offered an important portrait of women=s experiences during WWII. Writing about women who ferried airplanes for the Air Force, served as intelligence officers in Europe, worked in factories to produce war goods and more, she put a female face on the reality of war.

Later, when Vietnam nurses lobbied for recognition, a new realization of women=s contributions and trials on the front lines emerged.

Still, many a wartime heroine has gone unnoticed or been forgotten. Claire Chevrillon was one of them. An English teacher in Paris in 1942, she served in the French Resistance for three years. In 1943 she was arrested and imprisoned. AWhat I remember about arriving,@ she recalled, Awere the dark, subterranean, endless corridors through which I walked followed by a guard, as if in a nightmare.” Chevrillon survived and wrote a 1985 memoir. AThe instinct of one nation or race to dominate another doesn=t die,” she said. “It grows insidiously, feeding on private and public concern, until suddenly it=s too late to prevent disaster.@

Minnie Vautrin was an American missionary in China during the 1937 ARape of Nanking.@ Called the Goddess of Mercy for trying to save as many girls and women as possible, she repeatedly faced down threats and bayonets to provide asylum for refugees at the college she headed. A 1938 diary entry reveals her despair: AHow long will this terrible situation last? How can we bear it?@ In the end, Vautrin could not bear it. After helping women locate their husbands and sons at war’s end and teaching destitute widows how to survive, she returned to the U.S., committing suicide in 1941.

Ninety-nine Army and Navy nurses later known as the Angels of Bataan and Corregidor were captured in the Pacific by the Japanese during WWII. The first to be sent into the middle of battle, they became the only group of American women captured and imprisoned by an enemy. Before their incarceration, they helped build and staff hospitals in the middle of a malaria-infested jungle, pioneering triage nursing. Among them were women like Eleanor Garen, whose diary entry on a bad day read: AGaren, This is to yourself. Remember, life is not a bed of roses.@

An estimated eight to twelve thousand women served in the Vietnam War. Most of them were nurses; all had volunteered. Few were recognized as true veterans when they came home. One of them, Lily Jean Adams, was twenty-two years old when she worked as an intensive care nurse. She remembered what it was like comforting a dying soldier. ASometimes they would say >don=t leave me!= And I wouldn=t. I had an inner sense that this was just as important as taking care of the living.@

Women war journalists have been equally brave. Traditionally a male arena, war reporting obscured the trauma experienced by women and other civilians living in attacked areas. These noncombatants survive by fleeing to the hell of refugee camps, where sexual assault and other trauma is common. Today approximately a third of frontline journalists are female and they have a measurable influence on the content of war coverage. They follow models like Anna Benjamin, the first female photojournalist who covered the Spanish-American War, Mary Boyle O=Reilly, who was at the front in World War I, and Peggy Hull, who covered both World Wars and was the first accredited female American war correspondent.

Today women make up approximately 16% of American military forces and about 6% of veterans. Although women were not officially recognized as members of the Armed Forces until 1901, and then only as nurses, women have served in every major war in U.S. history. In WWI women who weren’t nurses could finally join the military; over 30,000 of them enlisted. During WWII women=s roles expanded and over 400 women of the 400,000 who served lost their lives. Desert Storm marked the largest deployment of women to a combat theater in U.S. history until the second Iraq war, with more than 40,000 women serving. Today women are graduating in ever larger numbers from U.S. military academies, often at the top of their class.

Frank Moore was right. The story of war will never be fully written or understood if the achievements and contributions of women are unrecognized. From soldiers to spies, nurses to Navy personnel, journalists to junior officers, veterans to wounded warrior wives, the stories of women in wartime must be told. The women at the center of those stories need to be honored, for they are women of courage, strength and resilience, not only now but as they have always been during wartime.

A Shout Out to the Bad Girls

It seems that bad girls are back. Not only that, they’re big. For starters there’s Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), the bane of Wall Street bankers, Rep. Tammy Duckworth (D-Ill.), who has been known to wear T-shirts claiming “Lucky for me he’s an ass man!” after losing both legs in combat, and Rep. Tammy Baldwin (D-Wis.), the fist openly gay woman to serve in Congress.

Tammy Duckworth

A few years ago several books celebrated bad girls, including Mario Vargas Llosa’s The Bad Girl and Bad Girls: 26 Writers Misbehave edited by Ellen Sussman. Well-Behaved Women Seldom Make History by Laurel Ulrich was a run-away best-seller. Her title even gave rise to a now iconic slogan.

Some of my favorite novels are about bad girls. There was Madame Bovary, of course, and Kate Chopin’s The Awakening in which the protagonist, Edna, gives up her secure middle class life because, like Bovary, she can no longer survive a loveless marriage, the ennui of noblesse oblige, or an existence in which nothing meaningful ever happens. There’s Nora in Ibsen’s classic The Doll’s House who breaks out of her child-wife existence. What about Elizabeth Bennett in Pride and Prejudice? She refuses to conform to social expectations for an 18th century young woman of marriageable age because she doesn’t believe in the conventions of her day. And dare I forget to mention my favorite bad girl and literary muse, Hester Prynne of Scarlet Letter fame? Imagine having an out-of-wedlock child in Puritan New England, fathered by none other than the local clergy!

Hester and Baby Pearl

Then there are the bad girls who write bad thoughts or foster bad ideas or whose female characters are bad, at least by patriarchal standards. Think of Elizabeth Cady Stanton and her pals who wrote furious, articulate, reasoned treatises in favor of bad women who wanted to vote. Or Virginia Woolf,

Bad Girl Virginia Woolf

whose essays, letters and diary entries focused on gender-based injustices or on the daily lives of women. There’s Collette, Marguerite Dumas and Erica Jong, who all wrote about steamy sex. And those diarists and memoirists like Maya Angelou and May Sarton who did what poet Muriel Rukeyser challenged all women to do: tell the truth about their lives. Speaking of poets, Sylvia Plath, Anne Sexton and Sharon Olds are among the bad girls. They aired their dirty laundry in public and opened a floodgate of 20th century truth-telling along with Adrienne Rich, Tillie Olsen and Grace Paley. Oh, Lord, so many splendid bad girls! A veritable feast of Blah Blah Sisterhood!

So what drives the image and the actions of the bad girl? From a traditionally patriarchal perspective it’s not hard to figure out. Bad girls are unafraid to exercise their power and that’s scary. Joyfully claiming their sexuality, they negotiate sex and sometimes “just say no.” They speak up and speak out. They don’t always do what they’re told, or what’s expected. They shake up the status quo. (Think of it – voting women who could make a difference!) Educated women are sure to be uppity, and unite, especially if they are economically independent.

The same holds true for why bad girls behave as they do. They may be wicked, ambitious, funny, admirable or brave; they may be from different generations, cultures or races, but they have this in common: They refuse to let society inhibit their imaginations, opportunities, or goals. They will not be controlled, in body or spirit. They may suffer but they never yield to forces trying to contain them. They deny dependency, suffocation, boredom, smallness. As Emma Bovary realized before her revolt, “A man is free, at least. Free to range,…to surmount obstacles, to taste the rarest of pleasures. Whereas a woman is continually thwarted.” What bad girls seek is the freedom to be, to act, to create, to go forth and experience the world. Who among us doesn’t share that longing?

Bad girls refuse to be thwarted or diminished. Their appetite for life is large and they are not ashamed to feed the hunger. Their answer to Freud’s question – “What do women want?” – is simple. They want it all and they are willing to take risks to get as much of it as they can. So they can sometimes be outrageous, but they are also admirable and often enviable. Their essential nature is writ large upon the tablet of history and literature and whether we like it or not, they have taught us all a thing or two.

So do yourself a favor: Find a bad girl to hang out with occasionally. You never know what you might learn and you could be surprised at how much fun it is being that risqué. As one of the world’s best bad girls, Mae West, said, just “keep cool and collect.”

The Heart of Birthing: Doulas and the Support They Offer

With the second annual World Doula Week having just ended, I’ve been reflecting once more on why I became a volunteer doula and what the work means to me.

I’m a baby freak, plain and simple. As a young candy-striper I routinely snuck into the pediatrics ward so I could rock sick kids. While my high school friends dated, I babysat. If I hadn’t been a product of the fifties, I might have considered becoming a obstetrician or a midwife. Instead I followed the path that most girls my age did: I went to college for a liberal arts degree and then became a secretary — a medical secretary.

My real career began when I became program director in 1979 for the National Women’s Health Network, a Washington, D.C.-based education and advocacy organization dedicated to humane, holistic, evidence-based, feminist approaches to women’s health care. In 1985 I went to Nairobi for the final international conference of the United Nations Decade for Women (1975-1985). Inspired by that amazing event and armed with a master’s degree in health communication, I began working internationally on behalf of women and children, always trying to bring a gender lens to the table.

In the midst of all this, I gave birth twice. My children were born in the seventies as the women’s health movement, and individual women, were beginning to advocate for natural childbirth and to resist the traumas of overly-medicalized birth experiences. We took Lamaze classes, learned about nursing, expected dads to be active in our deliveries. I was lucky: not only were my labors quick and unremarkable, but the small community hospital where I delivered was sympathetic to the changes taking place in birthing. There were no monitors, no drugs “to take the edge off” if you didn’t want them, no enemas, no shaving, and no macho-docs (although I couldn’t talk my doctor out of the episiotomy). I labored with my nurse and my husband and when the time came to push, I watched my babies come into this world in total awe of what had just happened and what I had done.

Several years ago, I learned that my local hospital had a volunteer doula program. Signing up was a no-brainer and I’ve now had the honor of supporting dozens of women and their partners as they’ve done the hard work of delivering a baby. Not one of them has failed to say afterwards, “I couldn’t have done it without you!” (They could, but I’m glad to have eased their experience.)

One of the early births I attended stands out in my mind. It was a first pregnancy and the mom labored stoically for thirty-six hours, pushing for five, before her son was born. As the hours passed, I held her hand, wet her lips, wiped strands of matted hair from her eyes, rubbed her back. “You can do this,” I whispered in her ear when she grew doubtful. “You’re doing a magnificent job! Soon your baby will be born.” As the baby finally crowned, wet, dark hair pressing urgently against her, I held the mother’s leg in my arm, her hand clenching my free wrist as she cried out with that guttural groan of a woman pushing her child to life outside the womb. And suddenly, there he was, head emerging, wet and pinking up even as his perfect little body swam into being. Later, swaddled and suckling at his mother’s breast, his father, eyes wet, whispered across the bed to me, “Women’s bodies are so miraculous!”

“Yes,” I said, my own eyes filling, “Miraculous.” Always miraculous, no matter how many times you give witness, or weep yourself to see a woman giving birth.

Doula supported childbirth has been proven to reduce the incidence of c-sections, shorten the length of labor, reduce the number of medicated births, increase breastfeeding and provide higher satisfaction for mothers regarding their birth experience. As one pediatrician put it, we are “the descendants of those millions of women who gathered at bedsides around the world” to help women through labor and delivery. “Some day we may again reach a point where women rely on the traditional circle of birth-experienced [women] to ease them through childbirth. … Until then, skilled, compassionate doulas will ably stand in for them.”

That is why I feel privileged to do this voluntary work. It is simply an honor to give witness to birth, and to offer as many women as possible the opportunity to have a birth that is supported, memorable, and full of joy.

Putting an End to ‘The Woman Question’

Recently Sigmund Freud’s irritating, macho-man question – “What do women want?” – has been making a comeback. Several television programs have addressed the question in interviews and soft news stories while exploring topics ranging from work/home issues to the role of activist nuns under a new papacy. A forthcoming book on “the science of female desire” (written by a man, of course) is actually titled “What Do Women Want?” Sigmund Freud

In an attempt to lay to rest once and for all the interminable query that causes men to continue scratching their heads, here are some basic answers.

First, we want the question itself to disappear. The fact that it keeps popping up as if females were a bizarre sub-species beyond human comprehension suggests that, despite growing numbers of women in governance, board rooms, military action, and more, we remain an enigma just for wanting to be part of life in all its sectors and social spheres.

We certainly want to be free from sexual and domestic violence no matter what we wear, where we go, and whether we have a few drinks with friends. Even after horrendous reports of gang rapes in India, including that of a Swiss tourist, and the Steubenville, OH rape of a 16-year old whose hideous assault went viral we continue to find ourselves counseled to behave defensively while perpetrators of rape and other violent crimes are shielded by their churches, universities, and workplaces. Why, we ask, are males not taught boundaries, respect for women, and behavioral norms that when violated accrue serious criminal consequences? And while we’re on the topic, we want the U.S. to join other civilized nations in ratifying the U.N. Convention to Eliminate All Forms of Discrimination Against Women, or CEDAW and to pass an Equal Rights Amendment.

We want our reproductive health and rights – our bodies – to remain in our own control, not that of opinionated, ill-informed, misogynistic men who blather on like Victorian pooh-bahs rather than 21st century humanists or civil rights advocates. That means men in Vatican Versace – think red shoes with matching chapeau – don’t get to keep us from accessing reliable contraception, or abortion if that is the agonizing, private decision we come to. Nor do Neanderthal politicians or bad boy bosses get to keep birth control pills out of reach. We are not forced to undergo medical rape or to die for the sake of a fetus as a woman in Ireland did recently. In short, as a group of brave women in Boston declared decades ago, “Our Bodies, Ourselves”!

April 9th being Equal Pay Day, we underscore that we want to earn wages equal to men. Despite some gains in workplace legislation (e.g., The Lily Ledbetter Act) we continue to be paid 77 percent, on average, of what men make even though equal pay for women is legally codified. That means a typical woman working full-time for the course of her career stands to have lost hundreds of thousands of dollars in income by the age of 65. No wonder “the feminization of poverty” continues to be a pressing issue for feminist analysts and economists.

Finding ways to balance work and home demands remains a challenge in all western societies but it would be nice if we could join the list of countries striving for gender equality in this realm. In Sweden, for example, according to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), men spend 177 minutes a day cooking, cleaning or caring for children, although women there still spend 259 minutes a day on domestic work. In Australia, both men and women devote approximately 14 hours per day to personal care and leisure. And in France, parents of two or more children can leave employment or reduce working time after childbirth and receive a flat-rate childcare benefit for up to three years. Is it really asking too much for American women to want safe, affordable day care so that they can earn a decent living without fearing for their children?

Finally, we want a seat at the tables of decision and policy-making and a place in discussions involving post-conflict resolution. Anyone watching Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY)

Kirstin Gillibrand

during recent hearings on sexual assault in the military could see the impact of having women legislators. In the business sector, even given recent gains for women as CEOs of major companies like Yahoo!, only 12 Fortune 500 companies and 25 Fortune 1000 companies had women CEOs or presidents as of 2009. And as writer Damilola Agbajobi has noted, “paying special attention to the different experiences of women and men is critical in designing successful conflict management and peacebuilding programmes.”

So, what do women want? It’s simple: Peace, personal security, a fair paycheck, the ability to parent well, and the right to rule our own bodies. Anyone who still has a problem understanding that ought to ask themselves what they want. If the answer is a win-win world, there should be no reason to resurrect Freud’s silly question, now or ever.

Sometimes Her Eyes Were Watchinjg God: Remembering Zora Neale Hurston

She was a complicated character, one that might have stepped off the pages of her own novels. Writer, folklorist and anthropologist, Zora Neale Hurston was a major force in the Harlem Renaissance, known among its artists for her wit, irreverence, and writing style. But she was also a thorn in the side of most black writers in that extraordinary movement because of her right-leaning political views and her ideology about the sanctity of isolated black culture.

A Barnard graduate and recipient of major fellowships, she was born in January 1891 and died in January 1960.

“I love myself when I am laughing … and then again when I am looking mean and impressive”

What is remembered most about Hurston, largely because writer Alice Walker resurrected her work during Second Wave feminism’s re-examination of women writers, is her lyrical prose about southern black culture. Perhaps her most famous novel, thanks to Walker, is

    Their Eyes Were Watching God,

the moving story of a black woman in the rural south and her three marriages. Set in Hurston’s home town of Eatonville, Fla. and published in 1937, it was praised for the beauty of the writing and the touching characters Hurston had created.

Eatonville was an idyllic place to Hurston. The fifth of eight children and the daughter of a Baptist preacher and tenant farmer who became the town’s mayor, Hurston loved the small enclave, the first incorporated black community in America. She saw it as a black utopia and in her essay “How It Feels to Be Colored Me” she remembered the town of 125 people like this:

“The only white people I knew passed through the town going to or coming from Orlando. The native whites rode dusty horses, the Northern tourists chugged down the sandy village road in automobiles. The town knew the Southerners and never stopped cane chewing when they passed. But the Northerners were something else again. They were peered at cautiously from behind curtains by the timid. … The front porch …was a gallery seat for me. I’d wave at [the passersby] and when they returned my salute, I would say something like this: ‘Howdy-do-well-I-thank-you-where-you-goin’?’ Usually [they] paused at this, and after a queer exchange of compliments, I would probably ‘go a piece of the way’ with them. … It is clear I was the first ‘welcome-to-our-state’ Floridian…”

Hurston’s mother died when she was thirteen and she was shunted off to various relatives until she was old enough to work as a domestic. In 1917, at the age of twenty-six, her Baltimore employer sent her to the high school that was to become Morgan State University. A year later she graduated and attended Howard University. In 1921 her first short story was published in the school’s literary magazine and soon she was recognized by leaders of the Harlem Renaissance. When she transferred to Barnard College she became a leading member of the movement.

Concurrent with the nascent black liberation movement in South Africa, the Harlem Renaissance sought to explore black culture and to exhibit pride in the black race in a variety of artistic forms. Hurston’s stories about Eatonville were a major force influencing the movement. However, she fell out of favor because critics thought she had failed to address racism adequately. Taking umbrage with her idealized portraits of black life in Eatonville, which they feared fostered segregation, many of her contemporaries felt she didn’t grasp the significance of the emerging civil rights movement.

Indeed, Hurston attacked the rights of blacks to vote in the south because she thought votes were being bought, and she argued against Brown vs. the Board of Education believing that black children didn’t need to attend school with whites in order to learn.

In the end, Zora Neale Hurston’s life was a reprise of the poverty and obscurity that had marked her childhood. Back in Florida, alone and sick, she died of heart failure in a county welfare home and was buried without fanfare in a public cemetery.

Despite her foibles and failures, Hurston’s early literary works deserve to be remembered and honored. Considered brilliant and illuminating by many of the great writers of our time, they paint a portrait of black culture that we might have otherwise been denied. Perhaps Hurston herself clarified the meaning of her contribution most clearly. “There is nothing to make you like other human beings,” she said, “so much as doing things for them.”

Remembering a Rape Victim and the Meaning of Her Death

It was a summer night in Florence, Italy. I was returning to my hotel after attending a concert at the Pitti Palace. Suddenly, five young men encircled me, hurling sexual innuendos. One of them smacked his lips and pointed to my crotch. I was sure they were going to gang rape me. The terror I felt was so intense I thought I would pass out. No one who has not experienced that kind of fear can understand what it feels like.

I was lucky. A passerby appeared and I was rescued. I was 23-years old, like Jyoti Singh Pandey, who was not rescued in India even though she was with her boyfriend. She was so brutally raped that what was done to her does not bear repeating. Suffice to say that she died of her injuries. Until her father released her name and picture we didn’t have a sense of her but as one blogger wrote, “I don’t need to see a photograph to cry for her.”

Violence against women in India has increased dramatically over the past two decades as women have become more autonomous. More than 600 rapes were reported in New Delhi alone last year and that number is small compared to those that don’t get reported. Even reporting rape can be dangerous. Recently an 18-year-old woman in Punjab State killed herself after police humiliated and then raped her themselves, admonishing her to marry one of her rapists, a remedy for the shame of rape often proposed by family members. Even as I write this, another gang rape on a bus has been reported.

But India isn’t alone in its murderous attempts to control women and to use them sexually as political pawns. The Women’s Media Center’s project Women Under Siege recently documented the horrific rapes of women in Syria, “usually by government forces.” Again, what has allegedly been done to young girls to sexually mutilate them doesn’t bear repeating. Congo is another case in point. In fact, there isn’t a country in conflict that doesn’t use rape and sexual assault as a form of intimidation and humiliation. And there isn’t a country in the world in which violence against women does not occur on a regular basis.

Here in America someone (overwhelmingly female) is sexually assaulted every two minutes. Mostly we don’t know about these incidents unless they are as heinous as the recent multiple rapes of an unconscious young woman in Steubenville, Ohio. Every year we average over 208,000 victims of reported sexual assault. Eighty percent of these victims are under age 30, 54 percent of assaults are never reported, and 97 percent of rapists never spend a day in jail.

No wonder most women are afraid, at some level of consciousness, to leave home, to travel alone, to dress the wrong way, to make eye contact with or to smile at someone they don’t know.

And what is our own government doing about it? Not much, thanks to the right wing of the wrong party. While the Violence Against Women Act was reauthorized in the Senate last year, some House Republicans failed to advance the Senate’s re-authorization because they didn’t think immigrant, Native America or gay women were worthy of being included in the Act. Sen. Patty Murray (D-Wash.) has vowed to re-introduce the legislation this year.

What is it in individuals and cultures that fosters, overlooks and perpetrates such heinous gender-based violence? How can such violations of women’s bodies, such physical and psychological cruelty, continue unabated? The answers are complex and go beyond theories that include the threat posed to patriarchies by self-determined women.

But Sandip Roy, a blogger who wrote about the Indian woman’s rape, offered some food for thought. There were lessons to be learned, he said, by the tragedy in India. (Many of them relate to the lessons of gun violence as well.)We learned, Roy said, that “it’s an exercise in futility to assign a hierarchy of rape as if one rape is more deserving of attention than the other.” We learned that “it is possible to shake a country out of its apathy” and that “if enough people raise their voices a government cannot ignore them.” We learned that “safety is not about what women do, wear or when they go out. It’s about what men around them do.”

“That girl could have been any one of us,” an Indian mother cried at a candlelight vigil for Jyoti Singh Pandey. “We can only tackle this by becoming Durga,” the Hindu god who slays demons, she said.

Let’s hope we can discover the Durga in all our countries and cultures, and that whatever gods we pray to give us the courage to confront the scourge of rape and other violence against women. Until we do, none of us can claim to be safe, or to assume we live in a civilized world.

January columns: DSM-5 & Michelle’s 2nd Term

WOMEN BEWARE!
DSM-5 COULD BE HAZARDOUS TO YOUR MENTAL HEALTH

Ava C., adopted from Asia and raised in small-town America, knew she looked different than her classmates, but no one ever talked about her origins. Over time, she began to withdraw. Following a psychiatric diagnosis of depression, she thought of herself as “mentally ill.” One day, while in a major city’s bustling Chinatown, she realized, “All around me were people who looked like me, doing ordinary things. They apparently didn’t feel ‘sick.’ That’s when my depression lifted.”

People like Ava — from different cultures, classes, races, or genders — often experience life’s stresses in unique ways. Too frequently they are labeled ill or abnormal by the psychiatric establishment.

Dr. George Albee, Emeritus Professor at the University of Vermont, once noted that “the highest rate of ‘idiocy and lunacy’ in America was first among the millions of immigrant poverty-stricken Irish after the potato crop failure of 1845, then on successive waves of poor Swedes, then Slavs and Russian Jews, then Southern Italians, now Blacks and Hispanics…as each group achieved economic success their incidence of ‘idiocy and lunacy’ fell to the population average.”

As the new Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, or DSM-5, is released this year, experts are sounding cautionary notes. Among the “psychiatrist’s bible” critics is Dr. Paula J. Caplan, a feminist psychologist who served as advisor to two DSM-4 committees before resigning due to concerns about “how fast and lose they play with the scientific research related to diagnosis.” Caplan has become the leading voice in alerting therapists and the public to the manual’s “unscientific nature and the dangers that believing in its objectivity poses.”

“It is widely believed …that if only a person gets the right psychiatric diagnosis, the therapist will know what kind of measures will be most helpful. Unfortunately, that is not usually the case,” Caplan says. “Getting a psychiatric diagnosis can often create more problems than it solves, including difficulties with obtaining health insurance, loss of employment, loss of child custody, the overlooking of physical illnesses…and the loss of the right to make decisions about one’s medical and legal affairs.”

Caplan worries that the authors of the DSM make “expansive claims about their knowledge and authority, wielding enormous power to decide who will and will not be called mentally ill and what the varieties of alleged mental illness will be.” She doesn’t deny that psychotherapy and medication can be helpful, but she sees worrisome connections between “drug companies’ concealment of the harm their products can cause and some professionals’ pushing of particular drugs while on the payroll of pharmaceutical companies.”

The American Psychiatric Association (APA), which writes the DSM, says its purpose is to establish criteria for diagnosis and “not to create medical conditions out of the full range of human behavior and emotions.” It also claims to be dedicated to “ensuring that the development of DMS-5 is the most open and inclusive in the history of the manual.”

Still, Caplan remains concerned about the “shroud of secrecy” that she sees enveloping the process. As director of the Coalition for Informed Patients and Doctors, she has called for Congressional hearings about psychiatric diagnosis “in an attempt to explore the nature and extent of harm that many Americans have suffered solely because of being given a psychiatric label.”

Feminist therapists are concerned for women in particular. Diagnoses such as Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) and Sexual Dysfunction have disparaged women and compromised them in troubling ways. For example, one expert says that BPD is almost exclusively applied to women because its symptoms relate to emotion and anger. Some women with the diagnosis have histories of abuse and may have difficulty expressing anger “appropriately.” Such vulnerable women need to have their coping styles better understood before assumptions are made about their behavior.

Similarly, “sexual dysfunction” among women is often based on assumptions about what constitutes normal sexual behavior. “If only performance failures or lack of desire count, the entire context of sexual activity becomes invisible and of secondary importance,” says one member of the Association of Women in Psychology (AWP).

Another AWP member focuses on classism in psychiatric diagnosis. “Poor women and women of color are particularly likely to be misdiagnosed or encounter bias in treatment,” she says. “Therapists may interpret chronic lateness or missed appointments as hostility or resistance to treatment rather than the outcomes of unreliable transportation, irregular shift work, and unpredictable child care arrangements.”

Caplan and her colleagues warn that “the absence of science creates a vacuum, and biases and distortions rush in.” Serious problems like depression are overlooked as people are diagnosed with unproven ‘mental illnesses’. “Many people who are suffering because of social problems like poverty or because they are victims of hate speech or violence are wrongly treated as though the problems come from within them.”

That’s enough to make anyone call for hearings instead of professional help.

**************************

WHAT WILL MICHELLE’S SECOND TERM LOOK LIKE?

I have enormous respect for Michelle Obama. She has brought dignity to the White House and set a high bar in terms of intelligence and style for first ladies to follow. Jodi Kantor, author of The Obamas, argues that this First Lady is a force to be reckoned with in the White House. Still, I wonder if she will now be a bit more 21st century in her role.

Ms. Obama’s nutrition initiative is good and so is her commitment to military families, although some say there’s more front than back there. Also, I understand that a lot occurs behind the scenes and that as a mom of adolescent girls, it’s important to put family first.

Still, as an experienced professional and a first lady with deep convictions, Ms. Obama has an extraordinary opportunity to address selected critical issues in this contentious time, and to exert her influence around current issues such as pay equity, violence against women, and reproductive rights. Instead, in her first term, she chose to be cautious, positioning herself as a traditional first lady addressing safe issues. She tread lightly, more akin to Nancy Reagan than to Hillary Clinton.

As first lady, Ms. Clinton set an extraordinary precedent. One can criticize her handling of the health care debacle, but not the fact that she took it on. Nor can you fail to admire her public commitment to women, even though she took a lot of heat for speaking out forcefully on their behalf. For those of us who watched her in Beijing at the 1995 Fourth World Conference on Women there was no more thrilling moment in the history of first ladies than when she read the riot act to the Chinese for their oppression of women.

Cataloging a litany of human rights abuses the world was stunned as Clinton declared, “It is time for us to say here in Beijing, and for the world to hear, that it is no longer acceptable to discuss women’s rights as separate from human rights.”

It’s not as though Clinton is the only former first lady who had fire in her belly. Eleanor Roosevelt was the most influential wife of a president this country has ever seen. She used her role to advance New Deal proposals, education reform, and equal rights for all in a time of violent racism. As her biographer Blanche Wiesen Cook noted, “Her gift for organizing and her astonishing energy and determination to do good combined with her famous name made her an influential figure in both social reform and partisan politics.” Involved with the League of Women Voters, the Women’s Trade Union League, and the Women’s Division of the New York State Democratic Committee, she wrote, “Against the men bosses, there must be women bosses who can talk as equals, with the backing of a coherent organization of women voters behind them.”

There were other first ladies who made their mark. Helen Taft advocated for women’s right to vote. Edith Wilson undertook many “details of government” when her husband Woodrow suffered a stroke. More recently Betty Ford transformed the role of first lady when she publicly confronted breast cancer as well as her battle with substance abuse. In 1991 she won the Presidential Medal of Freedom for “selfless, strong, and refreshing leadership on a number of issues,” including women’s rights.

The wife of the U.S. president can exert enormous influence on issues of her time. She has the ear of the president and her own bully pulpit. So Michelle, show us the real fire in your belly. What is it you truly want to speak out about or see changed? What do you want your legacy to be as a 21st century first lady?

You might as well go for it. As Eleanor Roosevelt said, “Do what you feel in your heart to be right, for you’ll be criticized anyway. You’ll be damned if you do, and damned if you don’t.”

Surely when you’ve got the right stuff – and you do, Michelle – it’s better to be damned if you do. So while you have this unique opportunity, why not go out there and make a big difference? As your husband would say, “Yes, you can.”

Are you “fired up and ready to go?”

Educating Congress, One Book at a Time

When Rep.Todd Akin, the Republican who sought Claire McCaskill’s Senate seat, declared that “if it’s a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down,” the women of the Boston Women’s Health Book Collective, now known as Our Bodies, Ourselves after their acclaimed book of that name, let out a collective gasp.

Then they took to the road. Delivering their iconic book to Akin as well as McCaskill on what they dubbed the “Missouri Sex-Ed Road Trip,” they quickly realized that Rep. Akin wasn’t the first or only member of Congress who had his facts wrong, and he probably wouldn’t be the last. So they took up readers’ suggestion that everyone involved in writing federal laws that affect women should have a copy of the widely respected Our Bodies, Ourselves.

Thus began a campaign aimed at educating Congress and informing policymakers on maternal health, preventive care, access to contraception, abortion and a full range of reproductive health services. “It would also serve as a resource on violence against women and a host of other issues that come up before Congress,” organizers said.

At an October National Press Club Newsmaker event in Washington, D.C. to launch the Educate Congress campaign, Judy Norsigian, founder and executive director of the Our Bodies Ourselves organization, said, “We hope to advance evidence-based reproductive health policy-making in this country” by giving copies of the book to all 435 members of the House of Representatives and 100 senators before the end of the year.

To that end OBOS is well on its way to raising $25,000 to cover the costs of distributing the paperback book which sells for the bargain price of $26 a copy. Originally published as a newsprint edition in 1971, Our Bodies Ourselves proved to be a pioneering, woman-centered study of women’s health and sexual issues. Today its 40th edition, weighing in at over 900 pages, shares the work of more than 350 experts and readers who worked collaboratively for more than two years to complete it. The book, which has sold over four million copies since its initial publication, has been translated into 30 languages and is recognized internationally as “the go-to authority” on women’s health and wellness. This year the Library of Congress included it in an exhibit of 88 books that “shaped America.”

In response to Akin’s comment about “legitimate rape” and Illinois Rep. Joe Walsh’s claim that because of “modern technology and science, you can’t find one instance” where an abortion was required to save the life of a mother, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecology (ACOG) issued two statements correcting the legislators’ false information about pregnancy and abortion. According to ACOG “many more women would die each year if they did not have access to abortion to protect their health or to save their lives.” Akin, Walsh and their uninformed, right-wing friends seem not to have heard of conditions such as pre-eclampsia (pregnancy-related high blood pressure), nor are they aware that the U.S. ranks 50th in the world for maternal deaths in childbirth.

They’re not the only ones who need educating, it appears. A medical student in Chicago reportedly told a professor that condoms aggravate the spread of HIV-AIDS. As Judy Norsigian says, “This country has a long way to go” when it comes to reproductive health education.

Norsigian, citing the clear need to provide Congress with accurate, evidence-based information, especially in the face of dangerous and uninformed comments being spewed about women’s bodies, said more politicians and their aides need to have a copy of Our Bodies, Ourselves readily available. This is especially important because the new edition focuses on topics that are sometimes misrepresented or misunderstood, such as pregnancy and childbirth, birth control and abortion, and sexual health.

The bottom line is this according to OBOS and other women’s health advocates: Congress can save women’s lives by advancing evidence-based reproductive health policy that, among other things, preserves access to and coverage of reproductive health care; improves maternity care and reduces maternal mortality; uses accurate language to describe rape; and ends restrictions on women’s access to safe abortion.

Not so long ago none of those markers seemed excessively demanding or difficult to achieve. Now they are under assault in unprecedented and frightening ways. Thankfully OBOS is there to help educate those most in need of solid, factual information, and to continue advocating in Congress and elsewhere on behalf of all women.

For more information, visit http://www.indiegogo.com/educate-congress

Re-posted by request:
In October 2011, I had the opportunity to spend two weeks volunteering as a doula in a hospital in Hargeisa, capital of Somaliland. What follows are excerpts from my journal about that experience.


The airplane which carries me from Dubai to Hargeisa, capital of Somaliland, is so old it looks like pieces of metal will fall off any minute. The tires are virtually bald and the interior is shocking with broken seats, filthy carpet, no working lights or air vents. There is no cabin crew and the aisles quickly fill up with luggage. There is the smell of urine and sweat. Upon arrival, people at immigration are shouting, shoving, snarling themselves up, barking orders that are ignored. I spot a man who must be my greeter. We drive to the hospital.

Edna, the founder and major domo of the hospital is stunning at 74 in her long dress and elegant head dress. She greets me warmly. I am shown to my room – a basic but perfectly adequate single with private bath in a dorm for visitors. I shower, unpack, and join the others for lunch. Along with Edna are a French physician who has come to do ‘hands on’ work after years in research medicine; a Finnish nurse-midwife and former missionary who has worked in Ethiopia and Somalia for most of her long career; a German-American nurse from New York City and another newly graduated nurse from Mass.; an OB-GYN from Germany; an energetic Austrian-born nurse-midwife now living in England; and an English nurse-midwife.

Lunch, like every other meal, is goat meat on the bone cooked with cabbage, a diced vegetable mix, rice, gravy with potato and carrot, salad, watermelon and bananas. There is fruit juice or bottled water to drink. (Breakfast is cereal, bread, a watery porridge and Somali pancakes.)

The hospital is smaller and less developed than I had thought but still the best hospital in Hargeisa. It is clean and equipped with one (rarely used) incubator, two (probably overused) ultrasound machines, and a decent delivery room and surgery. There is a lab, a library, Edna’s Computer Room, Edna’s Pharmacy, Edna’s Supermarket, and an ambulance on the well-guarded compound situated on a busy road unofficially called Edna Street. The hospital has a maternity wing and a medical-surgical wing which includes a room for pediatrics. It accommodates about 60 patients.

Many people mill about in the compound, most family members and visitors, some guards or other workers. The women, all in hijab and many fully covered with only eyes showing, stare curiously when I walk around the grounds. They do not allow me to take their picture. Several mosques surround the compound in this deeply Muslim country and there are frequent mullahs’ calls to prayer beginning at 4:30 a.m.
.
The history and politics of Somaliland are complex. Suffice to say that it is one of several colonized regions of Somalia that tried to unite for independence from France, Italy, and Britain in the 1960s but failed to coalesce effectively. Somaliland declared itself free and independent several decades ago and has been fighting for recognition as an independent nation since.

Somaliland is dry and dusty in the long absence of rain, and mostly flat with a pleasant climate at just over 4,000 ft. above sea level. It is one of the poorest countries I’ve ever seen. The canvas or wood business stalls, the goats in the road, the deeply pocked dirt roads, and the simple, inadequate houses (often no more than shacks made of corregated metal and rags) all provide a visual for the deep poverty here. Life expectancy for men is about 47; in the absence of data the high maternal and infant mortality rates are not known. Women are usually married between ages 15 to 25 and can expect to have between 5 and 12 pregnancies. FGM is universally practiced. It is a deeply religious culture and a mysterious place. I have no idea what is actually going on around me: I can’t understand a word that’s being said, and people outside the compound resist communicating (unless it’s to beg). They generally find us so aberrant as to be laughable. Many men are addicted to the local narcotic weed, khat, which they would sell their souls to chew.

The first night there I have my initial doula experience. The mom is about18; it is her first child. She labors so well I think she must be in early labor but she is on the delivery table (women always deliver in lithotomy position in a delivery room) and Asha, the midwife, is doing things that tell me the baby is coming. Mom moans and clings to my hand; I stroke her arm and whisper that she is strong and can do this; soon her baby will be born. A student nurse translates what I am saying. The mother nods to me. I support her head while she pushes; she grasps my arm. And then her son is born, his wet little head emerging first, then his body sliding quickly out. “Good job! Look at your little baby!” I tell Mom. “Thank you!” she says in English. “Thank you,” squeezing my hand. I go to bed happy that I’ve been able to help in this remote place.

On the morning of my second day I have my second birth. This is Mom’s third child and she too labors well, choosing to stand through most of her labor. Hibo is the midwife and a more gentle, calming, competent soul I’ve never met. I encourage Mom, massage her hips and back, stroke her arm, talk to her in whispers. Even when she doesn’t know what I’m saying I sense that she is comforted by my voice and my touch. As she leans on my shoulders she lays her against me as if she were a child. I stroke her head, reassuring her. At 9 cm. she climbs onto the delivery table. Hibo gently examines her, tells her when to push and when to stop. She is holding onto me for dear life. Three student nurses observe; I hope they are seeing the importance of emotional support during birth. Mom’s mom appears — I cannot tell from her expression if she thinks I am usurping her position, but then she says to Hibo, “This woman is beautiful the way she is helping my daughter.” A bigger reward I cannot imagine. Finally, a big, healthy boy is born. Mom thanks me profusely. I tell her I honor what she has done. She kisses my hand and thanks me again. I kiss her hand back and thank her. Hibo is not surprised by this exchange but the young nurses seem stunned at what they have just witnessed.

The next day a C-section is just beginning when I enter the OR in my scrubs and mask. Mom is getting an epidural. After she is draped the German doctor takes a scalpel and makes the first cut. Working quickly he opens the uterus and pulls out a baby who is hydrocephalic. “Very little brain,” he says. The baby also has a terrible hair lip and cleft palate. She does not breathe readily and is whisked off to be resuscitated. Hibo tells the family what has occurred. By the next morning the baby is dead.

I spend the next morning first on rounds in Maternity where four babies have been born during the night and a woman with eclampsia is in trouble, then in the Outpatient Department where the doctor is doing pre-natal checkups. I’m invited to palpate mothers’ tummies and to listen to the fetal heartbeat through a primitive wooden instrument.

With the other women I visit the local market. Crowded with stalls and not always easy for western women, we are in search of cloth from which traditional long dresses can be sewn. We quickly choose colorful cloth for $4 each and then find two women sitting at sewing machines who in no time stitch the material into full-length “moo-moo” like dresses. (Cost: $1). The women are friendly and try speaking to us as they sew on their antique machines. “Inshallah, I see you again!” one of them says when she is finished. “Inshallah,” I reply.

The next morning I wonder into the maternity ward. Four babies have been born during the night but no one is in labor. I visit baby Hodu, everyone’s favorite – a pretty six-month old little girl who keeps getting a dreadful infection on her head and face that has caused loss of pigmentation and scabbing. No one knows why she has this condition or why it recurs after treatment. Hodu is gorgeous but developmentally delayed. She faces an uncertain future. She lies in a bed all day with her young aunt watching over her

I help the mom with eclampsia who has had a C-section in the night because of her severe hypertension. Her baby boy is a fighter at 28 weeks and less than 3 lb. He seems to have a sucking reflex and has a good chance of survival if he can start nursing. For now, Mom pumps and feeds him through a syringe. I position the baby between his mother’s breasts, a technique known as Kangaroo Care which has shown good results for survival with premature babies. I wrap him in blankets and encourage the exhausted mom. Her mother is there along with a young aunt who speaks good English so we visit as I sit with them. Mom is expert at breastfeeding having had seven other children; she is able to squeeze out a few drops of colostrum and get them into the baby’s tiny mouth.

On Monday morning I hurry to the labor room where an induction is due to begin. Hibo tells me the husband has not yet given permission; he will come at 9 a.m. There are two other women in labor, and another woman awaits her husband’s signature for an induction. The chances are the men will not consent; they have likely consulted numerous family members. More likely, they will take their wives on a round of doctor visits until they find one who tells them what they want to hear.

I am beginning to see the dark side of this country and culture, where voiceless, disempowered women must have their husbands’ permission to have a C-section or an induction for medical reasons. (If they need a hysterectomy their father must agree – her body belongs to him.) I watch as husbands come to sign (or not), ignoring their laboring wives who walk the halls. Imperious and authoritarian, they swagger in and out self-importantly. The doctor says he has seen them deny their wife her life, even when she is crying to be rescued, because “Inshallah” it is God’s will (and maybe he doesn’t like this wife so much anymore.) He has seen babies die unnecessarily – “Inshallah”. A woman here often holds less value than a camel; she has absolutely no personhood. Her function in life is to marry, bear many children and obey her husband. Her body is not her own. She has no genitals remaining; by the age of nine or 10 they have been cut off. A husband expects to have sexual intercourse with his wife every morning and every evening, unless she is bleeding. No wonder women have upwards of nine to 12 pregnancies; they are not even given time to rest from the last pregnancy before their husband demands his right to enter her again. God only knows what kind of domestic abuse occurs in shacks and shanties throughout this country of ritual, tradition and male supremacy.

Watching women give birth here is something to behold; it is a testament to their strength and courage in the face of such a life. “She’s doing all the work and I’m doing all the sweating!” I tell Hibo as she delivers a woman’s ninth child. She makes no sound, not even a mild moan (Hibo says Somali women don’t do that) and suddenly her baby pops out. It is whisked away to be cleaned up and Mom seems little interested for the moment; she lies patiently waiting for the placenta to be delivered. Then, cleaned up, she gets off the delivery table as if nothing out of the ordinary has happened, and is taken to her room. I follow carrying the baby boy she has just delivered.

In Prenatal Clinic a variety of situations present: a woman is worried about her frequent miscarriages and infertility; another has back pain with her periods; several others are doing routine check-ups; a shy woman appears with her husband complaining of urinary retention post-C-Section. The doctor can hardly contain his rage at the father who took so long to give permission for the C-section that she has had complications.

There are two C-sections in rapid succession. I observe and take photos. I’m astounded at how fast they are; it is a relatively simple (but quite bloody) operative procedure requiring great skill nonetheless. The mothers are again stoic as they are catheterized, receive epidurals and lie exposed on the OR table. (There is an irony about the prevailing female modesty in this culture while at the same time women seem to disregard the lack of privacy surrounding their bodies in the hospital. Do they feel their bodies, which have been infantilized by the removal of sexual organs and pubic hair, are not their own?)

Wednesday I head for the wards at 9:00 a.m. Last night I missed a twin birth, a breech birth, a D&C and a prolapsed cord. Today in Prenatal Clinic there are lots of giggles among the patients and the friends they have brought with them, while the doctor, a pixy of a nurse and I joke back and forth between patients. The longer I’m here the more I like the Somali women I meet; they have a good sense of humor, are generally warm and appear to welcome our help. At lunch we are joined by an American missionary surgeon and his wife; the doctor can hardly control himself as he whispers to me, “Can you imagine going to Wyoming and telling people to change their ways?”

Thursday I teach 26 first-year nursing students about emotional support during labor and delivery. Before class I check to see what is happening in the maternity wing and find three women in labor. I visit briefly with each of them and promise a young new mom that I will return after my class to help her. She squeezes my hand. When I come back after class the midwife asks me where I have been. “The woman, she is asking for you. She says she want that lady!” The mom I promised to help has delivered her baby, asking for me the entire time! I go see her, apologize, and tell her how beautiful her new daughter is. “Next time, Inshallah!” I tell her. “Mashalla!” her mother says.

At the start of class I make small-talk with the students. Then we get down to business. I write “Doula” on the board and tell them it is Greek for “woman helper.” I explain what we do and why and then talk about the importance of emotional support for all patients. I tell them that in America we don’t always live close to our families like they do so we need others to help us when we are in pain or afraid. I talk about how caring is at the heart of good nursing. I tell them about birthing practices in the 1950s and 60s in America and how women got together to reclaim their childbirth experience (careful to use language they can understand). I demonstrate what doulas can say and do to make moms less afraid and more comfortable during labor. They seem rapt when I am speaking, mesmerized perhaps by this elderly white lady who talks of strange things, but when I ask them questions or want to know what their questions or thoughts are, they are silent. I say, “Allah gave you a voice! Women’s voices are beautiful! You must not be afraid to use your voice!” but this falls on deaf ears – they have been long socialized into silence.

I break the class into groups so that can practice techniques to support laboring mothers; they think the role play is hilarious and do not take it seriously so I reconvene the class and try a single demonstration; this too is seen as – quite literally – too funny for words. So I decide I’ve done what I can for one class and ask, in closing, that each of them tell me one thing they’ve learned today. A few whisper rote answers: “Massage.” “Breathing.” “Talk.” A few actually seem interested. To my amazement, one student says, “I learned that ‘doula’ means woman helper!” I am so excited I pretend to ululate; the others laugh and do the real thing. When a few other students say something audible and original I wave my hands in a Hallelujah gesture. I’ve gotten through to a few of them! I conclude with a pep talk about the difference good nurses make, the need to honor as well as support the hard and amazing work women do in having babies, the healing touch and so on. I invite questions but silence prevails.

And so it comes to an end, this African adventure of extremes, of wild animals and willful males, of voiceless women and vibrant girls, of outrageous poverty and obscene affluence, of deep blue seas and desert sands, of market stalls and mega-malls, of break-away nations and tradition-bound kingdoms, of visionary women and violent men. So much to absorb and try to understand; so much more to be done; so many new friends; such amazing experiences! May there be other such times in which to contribute and learn. Mashallah!

Why I Wrote It, and What the Critics Think!

Re-imagining Hester Prynne

The fortune cookie said, “A childhood book will have new meaning for you.”

I was eating Chinese with a group of women writers and discussing favorite books. I mentioned Nathaniel Hawthorne’s classic tale, The Scarlet Letter. Hester Prynne, I said, was my literary heroine. “But I wonder what ever happened to Pearl?” I mused.

That was it. Somewhere between the conversation and the cookie I knew I had to answer my own question. I also knew that I couldn’t write a historical novel; it just wasn’t in me. But I do know a lot about the Second Wave of the women’s movement. Why not put my Hester into the 20th century, replicate the main events of Hawthorne’s work within a contemporary, feminist context, then invent a life for Pearl?

So was born my first novel, Hester’s Daughters, published in January 2012.

The reason I loved The Scarlet Letter, even though like most high school students I couldn’t grasp altogether the extraordinary insight into human psychology that Hawthorne exhibited, was Hester. I was moved by her strength in the face of such isolation by her community; I admired her pride, and her absolute dignity. I loved that she embroidered the scarlet A worn on her bosom in such a way that it cast shame on those who looked upon it, not the woman who wore the mark of adultery. I admired how she came to be respected by the Puritans who had scorned her. I envied her empathy.

Hawthorne is said to have launched a new genre, the psychological romance. Both of those “tags” appeal to me. I am a romantic at heart with a good grasp of human psychology. In retelling the story of Hester Prynne through the lens of gender (and imagining Pearl as an adult who has her own love child), I hope I have honored Hawthorne and his characters.

Without a doubt they have enriched my life, and my literary aspirations.

~ ~ ~

What the critics are saying:

“It’s a wonderful book, full of life and truth. It made me laugh and cry. Beautiful!”

“Clift renders a stirring, contemporary retelling of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s classic. She captures the spirit of Hester and Pearl and recasts them in a dramatic, compelling and expansive story, cutting across time and culture to excavate connections that bind the hearts of women, no matter the century.”

“Clift delivers universal truths in complex packaging – so much so that if you have never read Hawthorne it could still be said that after reading Hester’s Daughters, you have… because the themes about the human condition that Hawthorne mined so well are just as compellingly revealed in Clift’s novel.”